Question:

Salamon Alaykom,

I have heard that Zubayr Al-Sabilbi married Asma Bint Abu Bakr by Mut'ah Marriage and from this union were born, Abdalliih Ibin Zubayr and Urwah Ibin Zubayr

Is this correct?

So does this mean that Temporary marriage was being practiced even in the time of Aboobakr?

Please note that this is the daughter of Aboobakr that is engaged, so it does not make sense to say maybe Aboobakr was not aware of this marriage.

Will appreciate a sufficient reply

 

Answer:


Wa alikum assalam wa rahmatullah wa baraktuh


First of all brother , Abdullah & Urwah are the sons of Alzubair ibn Al-Awwam not Zubayr Al-Sabilbi.

And there were not temporary marriage between Asma Bint Abu Bakr and anyone.

And for your information brother , Abdullah ibn Alzubair was very strict in the topic of Mutaa, he believe that it is haram and was very strict with the people who said it is halal in his time.

So how comes he was born from A Mutaa ( Temporary marrige )?!

As I said brother before , Shia used to lie sometimes to prove that they are correct !

Anyway , I want to add some hadeeths about Temporary marrige.

Hadith numeration in Sahih Muslim
'Ali bin Abi Talib, may Allah be pleased with him, reported: Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) prohibited on the Day of Khaibar the contracting of temporary marriage with women and the eating of the meat of domestic asses.

So the temporary marriage become Haram by this saying of the prophet & other sayings.

Then in the time of Umar ibn Al-khattab , Umar heard people saying that it is halal , and we didn't hear these from the prophet , then Umar made temporary marriage in the law, saying that if you still saying it is halal while it is haram and we call it in islam ( zina ) , now it is haram in the law , and if i catch anyone who practice it he will punished