Whilst the Ahl'ul Sunnah strive to portray a narrative of love and loyalty between Imam Ali (as) and the Shaykhain, the reality is far from their depiction. This became especially evident when Imam Ali (as) refused to accept a condition upon his appointment as Khalifa after being presented with the opportunity following the assassination of Umar. In light of this, Shia scholar and former Salafi Shaykh Marwan Khaleefat has posed 12 critical questions on the matter. Originally written in Arabic, the work was translated and restructured into Urdu by our dear brother Abdullah al-Imami, which we have now rendered into English.