7. Ibn Abi Sha’ybah distorted a narration in which a companion Walid bin ‘Uqbah drank wine !

by | Nov 14, 2023 | DECEPTION

Sa’eed bin Mansur (Died 227 AH) narrates like this : 

نا عيسى بن يونس، عن الأعمش، عن إبراهيم، عن علقمة، قال: كنا في جيش في أرض الروم، ومعنا حذيفة بن اليمان، وعلينا الوليد بن عقبة فشرب الخمر، فأردنا أن نحُدَّه، قال حذيفة: أتحدُّونَ أميركم؟ وقد دنوتم من عدوكم فيطمعون فيكم , فبلغه، فقال: لأشربن وإن كانت محرمة، ولأشربن على رغم من رغم

‘Alqamah narrates that we were with an army in the land of rome, With us was Huzaifa bin Al-Yaman and Al-Walid bin ‘Uqbah was leader (Ameer) upon us and he drank wine. So we decided to confront him. Huzaifa told : Do you wish to confront your leader ? The situation is you are sorrounded by enemies and they are seeking you. When this news reached Al-Walid he said : I will drink even if it is forbidden and I will drink no matter what you think.

Sunan – Sa’eed bin Mansur // Volume 2 // Page 197 // Number 2501 // Edn. Dar ul Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah Beriut Lebanon.

Now same narration is transmitted by Ibn Abi Sha’ybah via same chain but he has hidden the name of Al-Walid bin ‘Uqbah by saing “وعلينا رجل من قريش فشرب الخمر [and upon us was leader from Quraish who drank wine]  as he was brother of Uthman bin ‘Affan from his mother and a Companion.

Musanaf – Ibn Abi Sha’ybah // Volume 14 // Page 557 // Number 29466 // Edn. Dar Al-Minhaj Riyadh Saudi Arabia